| 1
| Season 1 Playoffs, Day 2, Game #000495 |
Mike Modano, St. Louis Eagles |
5 |
| 2
| Season 2 Playoffs, Day 7, Game #001022 |
Joe Sakic, Minnesota North Stars |
5 |
| 3
| Season 5 Playoffs, Day 1, Game #002626 |
Daniel Alfredsson, Boston Bruins |
5 |
| 4
| Season 6 Playoffs, Day 6, Game #003167 |
Vincent Lecavalier, Montreal Canadiens |
5 |
| 5
| Season 6 Playoffs, Day 6, Game #003168 |
Teemu Selanne, Ottawa Senators |
5 |
| 6
| Season 7 Playoffs, Day 3, Game #003751 |
Joe Sakic, Minnesota North Stars |
5 |
| 7
| Season 11 Playoffs, Day 3, Game #006116 |
Jean-Pierre Dumont, Minnesota North Stars |
5 |
| 8
| Season 1 Playoffs, Day 3, Game #000475 |
Alexei Zhamnov, St. Louis Eagles |
4 |
| 9
| Season 1 Playoffs, Day 2, Game #000495 |
Tony Amonte, St. Louis Eagles |
4 |
| 10
| Season 2 Playoffs, Day 3, Game #000983 |
Jaromir Jagr, Boston Bruins |
4 |
| 11
| Season 2 Playoffs, Day 4, Game #000988 |
Peter Forsberg, Winnipeg Jets |
4 |
| 12
| Season 2 Playoffs, Day 4, Game #000988 |
Milan Hejduk, Winnipeg Jets |
4 |
| 13
| Season 2 Playoffs, Day 1, Game #001003 |
Joe Sakic, Minnesota North Stars |
4 |
| 14
| Season 2 Playoffs, Day 1, Game #001003 |
Nicklas Lidstrom, Minnesota North Stars |
4 |
| 15
| Season 2 Playoffs, Day 5, Game #001011 |
Bill Guerin, Colorado Rockies |
4 |
| 16
| Season 2 Playoffs, Day 7, Game #001022 |
Nicklas Lidstrom, Minnesota North Stars |
4 |
| 17
| Season 2 Playoffs, Day 7, Game #001022 |
Brendan Shanahan, Minnesota North Stars |
4 |
| 18
| Season 3 Playoffs, Day 5, Game #001504 |
Chris Pronger, Toronto Maple Leafs |
4 |
| 19
| Season 3 Playoffs, Day 1, Game #001515 |
Sergei Zubov, Boston Bruins |
4 |
| 20
| Season 4 Playoffs, Day 3, Game #002047 |
Todd Bertuzzi, California Seals |
4 |
