| 1
| Season 5 Exhibition Season, Day 3, Game #002105 |
Mathieu Schneider, Boston Bruins |
27 |
| 2
| Season 9 Exhibition Season, Day 4, Game #004352 |
Donald Brashear, Quebec Nordiques |
27 |
| 3
| Season 13 Exhibition Season, Day 6, Game #006845 |
Sean Avery, Cleveland Barons |
27 |
| 4
| Season 7 Exhibition Season, Day 1, Game #003195 |
Sheldon Souray, Colorado Rockies |
22 |
| 5
| Season 6 Exhibition Season, Day 5, Game #002678 |
Bryan McCabe, Chicago Black Hawks |
20 |
| 6
| Season 7 Exhibition Season, Day 3, Game #003212 |
Sheldon Souray, Colorado Rockies |
20 |
| 7
| Season 9 Exhibition Season, Day 5, Game #004360 |
Craig Rivet, Colorado Rockies |
20 |
| 8
| Season 11 Exhibition Season, Day 5, Game #005477 |
Brendan Shanahan, Ottawa Senators |
20 |
| 9
| Season 11 Exhibition Season, Day 5, Game #005477 |
Craig Rivet, Colorado Rockies |
20 |
| 10
| Season 11 Exhibition Season, Day 5, Game #005483 |
Brendan Witt, Montreal Canadiens |
19 |
| 11
| Season 11 Exhibition Season, Day 6, Game #005487 |
Sheldon Souray, Ottawa Senators |
19 |
| 12
| Season 8 Exhibition Season, Day 3, Game #003780 |
Willie Mitchell, Atlanta Flames |
17 |
| 13
| Season 8 Exhibition Season, Day 6, Game #003805 |
Willie Mitchell, Atlanta Flames |
17 |
| 14
| Season 11 Exhibition Season, Day 6, Game #005490 |
Sean Avery, Cleveland Barons |
17 |
| 15
| Season 5 Exhibition Season, Day 4, Game #002107 |
Keith Tkachuk, California Seals |
16 |
| 16
| Season 5 Exhibition Season, Day 5, Game #002117 |
Ramzi Abid, Colorado Rockies |
16 |
| 17
| Season 13 Exhibition Season, Day 1, Game #006802 |
Chris Neil, Winnipeg Jets |
16 |
| 18
| Season 4 Exhibition Season, Day 3, Game #001551 |
Keith Tkachuk, Ottawa Senators |
15 |
| 19
| Season 5 Exhibition Season, Day 2, Game #002099 |
Stephane Quintal, New York Rangers |
15 |
| 20
| Season 5 Exhibition Season, Day 6, Game #002121 |
Robert Svehla, Pittsburgh Pirates |
15 |
